When Yahoo Tried to Restart Talks With Microsoft
"Yahoo trying to restart Microsoft talks" was real news — in the summer of 2008. It's the story of a rejected takeover bid, an activist investor's proxy fight, and a restart attempt that ultimately led somewhere very different from what either side originally proposed.
This refers to 2008 news, not a current or pending deal. After Microsoft withdrew its roughly $44.6 billion takeover bid for Yahoo in May 2008, activist investor Carl Icahn pushed for a new Yahoo board more open to a Microsoft deal, and Microsoft signaled it would restart talks if that happened. The eventual outcome wasn't an acquisition — it was a narrower 2009 search and advertising partnership instead.
The Background
In early 2008, Microsoft made an unsolicited offer to acquire Yahoo for roughly $44.6 billion, aiming to combine forces against Google's dominant position in search and online advertising. After months of negotiation over price — Yahoo reportedly wanted around $37 to $40 per share, while Microsoft's highest offer was lower — talks broke down entirely, and Microsoft formally withdrew its bid in early May 2008.
That withdrawal wasn't the end of the story. Within weeks, pressure began building — from inside and outside Yahoo — to get the two companies back to the table.
How It Unfolded
Carl Icahn's Role in Restarting Talks
After Microsoft's withdrawal, activist investor Carl Icahn built a significant stake in Yahoo and publicly argued the board had made a mistake by not accepting Microsoft's offer. He proposed an alternative slate of directors for Yahoo's board ahead of the company's annual shareholder meeting, framing it explicitly as a path back to a Microsoft deal.
Icahn's position
He argued the existing Yahoo board had failed shareholders by walking away from a lucrative offer.
Microsoft's response
Microsoft publicly signaled it would be willing to reopen talks — but only with a new board, not the existing one.
Yahoo's stance
Yahoo's leadership stated it remained open to reopening talks with Microsoft directly, disputing the need for a board change.
The resolution
Rather than a full proxy battle playing out, Icahn reached a settlement with Yahoo and joined its board instead.
Who Wanted What
Pushing for a restart
- Carl Icahn, who believed the original offer was worth pursuing
- Yahoo shareholders frustrated by the stock's decline after talks collapsed
- Microsoft, conditionally — but only with a board more open to a deal
Resistant or cautious
- Yahoo's existing board and CEO Jerry Yang, who had resisted the original terms
- Microsoft's own stated position by mid-2008, that it was no longer pursuing a full acquisition under those terms
What Actually Happened Instead
The restart-talks period didn't produce an acquisition. Yahoo's leadership changed — Jerry Yang stepped down as CEO in November 2008, and Carol Bartz took over in early 2009 — and under that new leadership, Microsoft and Yahoo reopened discussions on very different terms: not a takeover, but a 10-year search and advertising partnership, announced in mid-2009.
Why This History Is Still Worth Knowing
Beyond the specific companies, this episode is a useful reminder of how corporate deal talks actually play out in practice: rarely as a single clean negotiation, and often shaped as much by shareholder pressure and leadership change as by the original strategic logic. The deal that eventually happened — the 2009 search partnership — looked quite different from the acquisition both sides had spent most of 2008 fighting over.
Track Your Own Search & Ad Performance With MarketHealth
Platform relationships and ownership change over time — MarketHealth provides tracking links so you can measure how your own traffic performs regardless of which search or ad platforms you use. Review the programme terms for your traffic source, then create your account to get started.
Join MarketHealthFrequently Asked Questions
Is Yahoo currently trying to restart talks with Microsoft?
Did Microsoft eventually acquire Yahoo?
What was Carl Icahn's role in this story?
Why did the original Microsoft-Yahoo acquisition talks fail?
What eventually came out of this saga?
A Note on This Article
This article covers the history of Microsoft's 2008 attempt to acquire Yahoo and the subsequent effort to restart talks, presented as historical context rather than current or pending news. These events are from 2008; the eventual outcome — a 2009 search and advertising partnership rather than an acquisition — has itself been renegotiated multiple times since. Verify current details against a recent, dated source if needed.